Who Won the Russo-Japanese War?

At the turn of the 20th century a major war broke out between a European power and a rising Asian power in the Far East. The question of who won the Russo-Japanese war would be settled in a decisive manner.

The dynamic behind the Russo-Japanese war and its beginnings are multi-faceted. The Japanese were an emerging threat in the Far East ever since the reforms enacted through the Meiji Restoration in the mid-19th century.

Their victory in the First Sino-Japanese War from 1894-1895 cemented the belief by Western powers that Japan, not China, was now the dominant force in East Asia. As a result of the war, Japan also extended its sphere of influence in the region into Manchuria and the Korean peninsula.

This directly clashed with Russia’s own imperialist agenda. Throughout the 19th century the Russian Empire gradually gobbled up more and more territory in Asia. Eventually the empire stretched all the way in the east to the Kamchatka peninsula.

Russia had further ambitions in the region, including finding a better location to house their eastern naval fleet. Their main naval base of Vladivostok was located far north, and sea-ice often interrupted military and commercial activity.

Inevitably Russian and Japanese ambitions in Manchuria and Korea would lead to the Russo-Japanese war of 1904-1905. Japan would stun the world with a decisive victory that humiliated the Russians.

The war had various aftereffects and was a major influence in the future two global conflicts known as World Wars I and II.

What Started the Russo-Japanese War?

In the aftermath of the Sino-Japanese War of 1894-1895, the “Triple Intervention” of Russia, France, and Germany forced Japan to agree to more lenient peace terms with China.

In the peace treaty, Japan was required to withdraw from the Liaodong peninsula and Port Arthur in southern Manchuria and abandon the further territorial gains it sought.

Japan felt the European powers cheated it from its rightful spoils of war. The animosity grew even further when Russia immediately occupied Port Arthur and the Liaodong peninsula and the other European powers seized Chinese ports under various contexts.

Russia entered the region for both economic and military reasons. Russian greed for timber and mining near the Yalu river bordering Korea influenced its actions. Militarily, Port Arthur would serve as the further south warm water port that could house the Russian Pacific Fleet.

As Japan viewed southern Manchuria and Korea as within its sphere of influence, tensions quickly arose in the region. The situation became worse following the Boxer Rebellion in 1900.

Map of the significant events and results of the Russo-Japanese war via portsmouthpeacetreaty.com

In response, Russia sent hundreds of thousands of troops pouring into Manchura to protect its various railways under construction such as the Chinese Eastern Railway and South Manchuria Railway connecting Port Arthur.

Though Russia promised to remove these troops in the aftermath of the rebellion, they gave no time table. The troops were still present in Manchuria by 1903, leading Japan to pursue diplomacy in its quest to further define its sphere of influence and avoid war with the threatening Russians.

The Russian monarchy scoffed at the idea of compromising with an inferior Asian nation. Racial prejudices common at the time no doubt played a role in the Russian overconfidence.

Tsar Nicholas II intentionally stalled negotiations as he did not believe Japan would dare go to war with the mighty Russians.

However, Japan indeed chose war with the Russians, likely bolstered by their 1902 alliance with  Britain. Japan hoped this alliance would keep other European nations out of the war.

Russo-Japanese War Timeline

1904

The Russo-Japanese war began with a Japanese surprise attack on Port Arthur on February 8, 1904. Like the attack on Pearl Harbor nearly three decades later, Japan attacked hours before an official declaration of war was received.

The Japanese sought to catch the Russians unprepared and deal a devastating blow to their Pacific fleet housed at Port Arthur. The attack ended inconclusively, as Russian shore batteries were able to protect against the worst of the attack.

Despite this, the battle proved to be a huge psychological victory for Japan and showed the Russians this conflict would not be the easy victory they had been expecting.

From there, the Japanese blockaded Port Arthur to prevent the Russian fleet from interfering with their troops’ movements. By early August, Japan was in position to lay siege to the port city by land and sea.

Timeline of the 1904-1905 Russo-Japanese War chart

The Russian fleet attempted to escape, though in the corresponding Battle of the Yellow Sea enough ships were heavily damaged that they were forced to turn back to the port.

In December, the Japanese captured a strategic position in the hills surrounding Port Arthur. From this vantage point the Japanese howitzers could shell the Russian navy at port. One by one the Japanese guns systematically destroyed ships until the Russian Pacific Fleet was wiped out.

Fearing the worst, the Russian leader at Port Arthur surrendered the city to the Japanese in January 1905.

Meanwhile the Russians and Japanese engaged in several land battles in 1904. The Battles of the Yalu River in April, Nanshan in May, and Shaho in October were all vicious engagements that led to high casualties on both sides.

Shockingly, the Japanese continued to hand the Russians tactical and strategic defeats.

1905

This trend continued on the land in early 1905. At the battles of Sandepu and Mukden, Japan once again sent the Russians fleeing and the fanatical Japanese offensives unnerved the enemy.

Though the Russians were handed several losses on land, their army remained intact and always a threat with their seemingly unlimited supply of manpower. A Japanese victory would need to be secured through their navy.

In October 1904 the situation at Port Arthur was looking dire. With the Pacific Fleet trapped, the Russians ordered their Baltic Fleet to sail all the way from the Baltic Sea to Port Arthur to relieve the Japanese blockade.

The journey would be over 18,000 miles and require the fleet to sail around the tip of Africa. The trip was a monumental logistical undertaking. As Russia was at war, the fleet could not refuel with coal at any neutral port and thus were required to stay in international waters.

Route of Russian Baltic Fleet to the Far East

The trip was not without its blunders. In the Dogger Bank Incident, the Baltic Fleet mistakenly fired upon British fishing ships, killing three people. The paranoid Russians mistakenly believed the fishing ships were Japanese torpedo boats.

After nearly seven months the Baltic Fleet finally made it to the region only to find that Port Arthur had already surrendered. Worse, the Japanese fleet knew they were coming and were waiting for them.

At the Battle of Tsushima in May 1945 the Japanese were able to “cross the T” – a naval maneuver where the attackers can utilize their broadside guns while the defenders can only use their forward turrets.

After the incredibly long journey, the Russian fleet was virtually annihilated during the two day battle.

The defeat was so absolute that it was the last major confrontation of the war. The humiliating defeat and utter destruction of two of their three naval fleets finally brought the Russians to the peace table.

Who Won the Russo-Japanese War?

The question of who won the Russo-Japanese war is easily answered: the Japanese stunned the world with a complete and dominant victory over the Russians.

After the Battle of Tsushima both countries were eager to end the conflict. Despite the Japanese domination, the heavy casualties on both sides and the massive economic cost of financing the war was draining both nations.

The Japanese requested that US President Theodore Roosevelt mediate peace talks. Roosevelt aimed for both parties to come out content with an agreement, though following through would be nearly impossible.

Partially sunken ships of the Russian Pacific fleet

Japan was adamant that Russia pay an indemnity for their war costs and to cede Sakhalin Island north of Japan. The proud Russians refused both charges, and likely were too financially constrained to make any reparation payments if required to do so.

The Treaty of Portsmouth was begrudgingly signed in September 1905, officially ending the war.

Japan won its hard-fought control over Korea and South Manchuria as well as half of Sakhalin Island. The Russians had to vastly reduce their influence in the region, but maintained some control and weren’t required to pay an indemnity.

Though the terms were favorable to Japan, the Japanese public was furious over the lack of an indemnity. Animosity arose once again over being “cheated” of the spoils of war in their dominant victory.

That hatred was especially pointed towards the United States over its alleged role in mediating the peace talks and helping the defeated Russia to more favorable terms. This animosity would only grow over the following decades as the US extended its own imperialistic tendencies further into the Pacific.

The Significance of the Russo-Japanese War

The Russo-Japanese war held great significance and served as a precursor for what was to come in the following decades.

The entire war was followed very closely in the media with war correspondents on both sides. Major troop movements were extensively covered as well, such as the whereabouts of the Russian Baltic fleet as it traveled around the world.

This level of coverage and worldwide attention was a precursor for the major wars to follow. In addition, several major revelations were made regarding the power of new technology and weapons.

The Battle of Tsushima proved that battleships with all long-range guns were the dominant naval vessel of the time. Going into the war, navies preferred ships with a combination of short-, mid-, and long-range guns.

The Battle of Mukden was a precursor to the fighting in World War I. Mukden was likely the largest battle in world history at that point in terms of number of participating troops. The high casualty counts would also be replicated in the next global conflict.

The new technology of machine guns and long-range artillery would prove to be extraordinarily deadly. European military observers failed to learn from the war and would repeat some of the worst blunders on the Western Front of World War I.

Perhaps most importantly, the prestige and perceived threat of Russian power was greatly diminished after the Russo-Japanese war. The Russian failure to defeat an Asian nation was humiliating and devastating to the Romanov dynasty. Just a decade later their rule would end.

The Russians were held in such contempt that German war planning, including the famed Schlieffen Plan of WWI, accounted for the relative weakness of the Russians.

The Japanese were catapulted onto the world stage with the victory. The confidence gained in winning the war would translate into more aggressive actions and spark further conflict in the following decades.

Though little known, the Russo-Japanese war played a large role in spurring on the events of the following decades.

Like what you see? Subscribe to Posts!

Leave a Reply